Protestants & Politics

News, Opinion, Research, Books

June 15, 2020

News

1. The US Supreme Court issued a ruling in a religious freedom vs. gay rights case. 

 

Washington Post: 

The Supreme Court ruled Monday that federal anti-discrimination laws protect gay and transgender employees, a major gay rights ruling written by one of the court’s most conservative justices.

 

Justice Neil M. Gorsuch and Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. joined the court’s liberals in the 6 to 3 ruling. They said Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits discrimination “because of sex,” includes LGBTQ employees.

 

The opinion in pdf here. 

 

From the majority, authored by Gorscuch: 

In Title VII, Congress adopted broad language making it illegal for an employer to rely on an employee’s sex when deciding to fire that employee. We do not hesitate to recognize today a necessary consequence of that legislative choice: An employer who fires an individual merely for being gay or transgender defies the law. 

 

From the dissent authored by Alito, joined by Thomas: 

The Court tries to convince readers that it is merely enforcing the terms of the statute, but that is preposterous. Even as understood today, the concept of discrimination because of “sex” is different from discrimination because of “sexual orientation” or “gender identity.”

 

Conservative reactions on Twitter: 

SCOTUS opinion is devastating for religious liberty. It just gave the spirit of the Equality Act in a legal opinion, rather than in statute. Gorsuch writing the opinion eviscerates the main rationale that religious conservatives have in voting for Trump. "But Gorsuch" is moot. -Andrew T. Walker

 

Thanks to two GOP appointees -- Roberts and Gorsuch --  churches and schools that discriminate against LGBTs stand at risk of losing tax-exempt status, per the Bob Jones ruling. Hard to overstate the magnitude of this loss for religious conservatives. -Rod Dreher

 

Douthat recently suggested that Trump would usher in a progressive backlash—going forward. Still, socons could at least boast of the lifetime judicial appointments their Faustian bargain garnered them. But what do they have to show for it? Tired of winning, yet? -Matt Lewis

 

2. Relatedly, on Friday, HHS overturned an Obama-era "transgender mandate" that interpreted "sex" to also mean gender identity. 

 

Coverage at Politico or World.

 

HHS rule here.  

 

Reaction from Becket, which was concerned about requiring doctors to perform gender transition surgeries against their religious beliefs, here. 

 

3. "More Christians are saying black lives matter. But faith-based support for the police runs deep" 

Across the country, support for the Black Lives Matter movement is surging, including in religious communities.

...

From a historical perspective, these statements and actions are somewhat remarkable, according to scholars who study the relationship between personal faith and policing. For much of the past century, many Christians ignored or refuted reports of racial disparities in police work.

 

Opinion

1. Timothy Dalrymple, "Justice Too Long Delayed: It’s time for the church to make restitution for racial sin." 

Today’s generations may say we did not invent the bull of racial injustice. But we have benefited from it. The resiliency, creativity, industry, and indomitable faith of African Americans in spite of all they have suffered is nothing short of miraculous. We have all benefited not only from their labor but also from their innovations and entrepreneurialism, their art and music, their films and poetry and books, their hymns and preaching. The transformation of black suffering into economic abundance for America, as well as art and passion and brilliance, has enriched our feast in the palace. Perhaps we can honestly say we did not know what our brothers and sisters were suffering. Now we do. So there’s only one thing to do: put down our forks and get our brothers and sisters out of the belly of the bull.

 

2. Skye Jethani, "Donald Trump’s Bible or George Floyd’s? That's the choice facing America’s Christians. Donald Trump sees the Bible as a political prop. For George Floyd, it was a path to peace, justice and healing. America needs that now more than ever."

As I continued to witness how eager many evangelicals were to dismiss Jesus’ words, I began to understand the negative perception the broader culture has of Christians. Although Christians often claim to be marginalized for taking Jesus too seriously, I’m convinced it’s the opposite. The negative perception of evangelicals in America is caused by our not taking Jesus seriously enough. Venerating the Scriptures while disregarding their teachings is exactly why Jesus called the religious leaders of his day “hypocrites,” “serpents,” and “whitewashed tombs that outwardly appear beautiful, but within are full of dead people’s bones.”

 

3. Chris Hall, "We Have Refused to Listen: The murder of George Floyd calls us to repentance" 

Together, we grieve the events of these past days. We lament, though, not simply the recent days. The voices and actions of injustice are long. Months, years, centuries have swept by, leaving in their bloody wake the troubled waters of pain, sorrow, terror, cruelty, and death. “Lord, do you not see the suffering of your people? Do you not care? How long, Lord? How long?”
 

As I sit with them, I sense the Lord speaking. He is calling us to repentance. The Holy Trinity calls to me and to the white Christians of our nation. We bow the knee. We make no excuses. We name our sin as specifically as possible. We ask for grace for genuine repentance. And we pray: “Lord, have mercy.”

 

4. BBC Radio: No Justice, No Peace: Religion and Protest

 

5. Video: Message from NAE Leaders on Racial Justice & Equality

Research

1. "The Political Implications of End Times Belief" 

Conservative elites, from Trump to members of Congress to interest group leaders, have been peddling extreme arguments that Democrats will strip the rights and liberties of Christians if given control of the federal government. ... I’m starting to call these “end of democracy” arguments, because once you believe the other side will strip you of your freedom and ability to petition government, then there is little value in investing in democratic processes.

 

Are end times believers more likely to be exposed to such arguments? Yes, but only if they attend church.

 

Books

1. Mark Galli, When Did We Start Forgetting God? The Root of the Evangelical Crisis and Hope for the Future

 

Review at TGC.

 

2. Kaitlyn Schiess, The Liturgy of Politics: Spiritual Formation for the Sake of Our Neighbor

 

3. The Spiritual Danger of Donald Trump: 30 Evangelical Christians on Justice, Truth, and Moral Integrity 

Subscribers to this newsletter can get a copy for 40% off with the code DANGER40. I'll be giving away another free copy to one, maybe two, subscribers to this newsletter. Stay tuned for more info.

 

Follow Me
Follow on Facebook
Follow on X (Twitter)
Sign up for this newsletter
Subscribe

Share on social

Share on FacebookShare on X (Twitter)Share on Pinterest

Check out my website  
This email was created with Wix.‌ Discover More